Hand Made, Small Batch Fishing Lures

Shop all

BTJ “Support your local tackle pusher” 100% Cotton T-shirt!

$31.00

View Product

(BTJ Exclusive!) Platinum Pumpkin Seed Spinners

$26.00

View Product

(BTJ Exclusive) “Snakehead family picnic” Spinner Baits!

$26.00

View Product

Premium Spinner Baits

$12.50

View Product

Johnnys Secret Worms (The Mann’s Mannipulator 15pk) -1985

$12.00

View Product

Choke Hold Clatter Baits (Direct Connect)

$9.99

View Product

Flippin Jigs! (Hidden Line Tie)

$5.25

View Product

Frog Head Buzz Baits

$10.50

View Product

Let customers speak for us

from 68 reviews

The best spinners around! Handcrafted and made with love.

Ken Nyberg

04/27/2026

“The Old Timer” 3/8-oz Buck Tail Clatter Baits

Amazing hand crafted, awesome action in the water. Could be any better. Super happy will be ordering more.

Devin Sakach

03/19/2026

Robo-Gill!-3/8-oz Original Bladed Jigs

I purchased several jigs but didn’t see the weight I wanted. I reached out to Buck Tail Johnny’s and he made me the 3/8 size weight I wanted. Super good communication and fast shipping. Can’t beat the prices of these custom jigs!

Kevin Mahoney

02/16/2026

Buck Tail Johnnys Lure Co.

Love the color combo. I have the perfect lake for this jig with the most vibrant sunfish.

Kevin Mahoney

02/16/2026

Johnnys Secret Worms (The Mann’s Mannipulator 15pk) -1985

Buck tail Jonny’s pop up on my instagram feed and thought they looked amazing. Purchased three jigs and a buzz bait. The color combos are awesome and the feather feature on the buzz bait gave it that extra pop, Jonny’s have really nice quality and the price is super affordable. I can’t wait to fish these when this ice thaws up herein New England.

Kevin Mahoney

02/16/2026

Frog Head Buzz Baits

Crazy good quality, never seen one like it but the fish sure do love them, great work johnny

Frank S.

02/15/2026

Frog Head Buzz Baits

Its gorgeous and quality printing

Aaron Leanza

06/03/2026

Custom BTJ Stickers!

Great customer service!

Aaron Leanza

05/22/2026

Buck Tail Johnnys Lure Co.

My package arrived today, and I’m genuinely impressed. These fishing lures are on another level. The attention to detail, color combinations, and craftsmanship make them look more like custom artwork than tackle. You can tell a lot of thought went into every design. Pictures honestly don’t do them justice. If you’re serious about fishing and want lures that stand out both in quality and appearance, I highly recommend giving these a try.

Aaron Leanza

05/22/2026